
Cookie walls and the GDPR: content blocked until you accept
At a glance
EU-23HighGDPR Arts. 4(11) and 7(4), recital 43; ePrivacy Art. 5(3) and recital 25; EDPB Guidelines 05/2020, paras. 39 to 41; EDPB Cookie Banner Taskforce report (2023), para. 13
Peeky checks whether your pages can be used without accepting cookies, and what a pay-or-accept wall asks visitors to agree to.
Last checked against the source:
The rule
The EDPB’s consent guidelines of 4 May 2020 say: “In order for consent to be freely given, access to services and functionalities must not be made conditional on the consent of a user to the storing of information, or gaining of access to information already stored, in the terminal equipment of a user (so called cookie walls).” Example 6a describes “a script that will block content from being visible except for a request to accept cookies”. There is “no possibility to access the content without clicking on the ‘Accept cookies’ button”, and “since the data subject is not presented with a genuine choice, its consent is not freely given.”
The EDPB builds that on the GDPR’s definition of consent.
Article 4(11) defines consent as a “freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous indication of the data subject’s wishes”. Article 7(4) says that when judging whether consent is freely given, “utmost account shall be taken of whether, inter alia, the performance of a contract, including the provision of a service, is conditional on consent to the processing of personal data that is not necessary for the performance of that contract.” Recital 43 adds that consent “is presumed not to be freely given” if it does not allow separate consent for different processing operations where that would be appropriate, or if the service “is dependent on the consent despite such consent not being necessary for such performance.”
Cookies come in through Article 5(3) of the ePrivacy Directive, which since 2009 allows storing or reading information on a visitor’s device only once the visitor “has given his or her consent”. The EDPB says the GDPR’s conditions for consent apply there too. Publishers who defend walls often point to recital 25 of the original 2002 directive: “Access to specific website content may still be made conditional on the well-informed acceptance of a cookie or similar device, if it is used for a legitimate purpose.” That recital was written when Article 5(3) asked only for information and a right to refuse.
The EDPB’s guidelines leave one opening. An equivalent service from the same controller that doesn’t ask for consent to the extra use means “there is no longer a conditional service”, provided both are “genuinely equivalent” (para. 37). An alternative offered by another company never counts (para. 38). The Cookie Banner Taskforce added in 2023 that a banner must not give users “the impression that they have to give a consent to access the website content” (para. 13).
That second door is “pay or OK”, also called consent or pay. The Court of Justice touched on it in Meta v Bundeskartellamt (C-252/21, 4 July 2023): users who refuse processing a contract doesn’t need should be “offered, if necessary for an appropriate fee, an equivalent alternative not accompanied by such data processing operations” (para. 150). The EDPB’s Opinion 08/2024 of 17 April 2024 is limited to large online platforms, and says that “in most cases” they can’t obtain valid consent with a plain choice between consenting to behavioural advertising and paying. The EDPB announced broader guidelines on consent or pay in 2024. Its work programme of 12 February 2026 still lists them as in progress, and none were adopted as of 4 November 2026.
Until then the national regulators set the terms. The Dutch AP said on 7 March 2019 that with a cookie wall, where no consent means no access, consent isn’t freely given. In France the Conseil d’État annulled the CNIL’s general ban on walls on 19 June 2020 as more than soft law can do. The CNIL’s criteria of 16 May 2022 now ask for a real and fair alternative, a reasonable price, a wall limited to the purposes that pay for the service, and no tracker needing consent in the paid version. Germany’s Datenschutzkonferenz accepted paid tracking-free subscriptions on 22 March 2023, with equivalent access at a market-standard price, only strictly necessary storage for subscribers, and granular consent where purposes differ. Denmark’s Datatilsynet held in 2023 and 2024 that only the marketing purpose can be tied to a paid alternative. The AEPD’s guide, updated in May 2024, rules out walls with no alternative, and says the alternative may be “no necesariamente gratuita” (not necessarily free). The Garante’s guidelines of 10 June 2021 accept a wall only where the site offers equivalent content or services without consent, judged case by case.
Enforcement follows the two tracks of the law. The conditions for consent sit in the GDPR’s upper fine tier, Article 83(5)(a). The cookie rule itself is enforced under each country’s ePrivacy law, as the AEPD did with Article 22.2 of the Spanish e-commerce law in the Iberia case.
What PeekWell checks and how
EU-23 asks one question: can a visitor use the page without accepting? The scan answers it from what the page does before anyone has chosen.
The scan is automated. It opens your public pages the way a first-time visitor’s browser would, with nothing saved, and never clicks Accept to get in. It treats a consent layer as a wall when it keeps the content out of use: it covers the content or the screen, the page stops scrolling, the content is hidden or marked inert, and a click on the content lands on the layer instead. Then it refuses, and separately accepts, to see whether the content opens either way.
There are two ways to fail:
- The only way past the wall is Accept. There’s no reject or “continue without accepting” control that leads to the content, or the one there is leads back to the wall or to another request for consent. Peeky reports this at high severity.
- The only other way in is a subscription or payment, and Accept gives consent to more than the payment replaces, such as analytics, social media or personalisation on top of the advertising that funds the site, with no way to refuse those separately. Peeky reports this pay-or-OK bundle one step lower, at medium.
The check passes when the content can be used after refusing or without answering. A pay-or-OK wall passes when Accept covers only the purposes the paid option replaces, or the others can be refused one by one. The finding then says what was seen, and that the price, the equivalence of the paid version and the tracking inside it weren’t tested, because the scan doesn’t subscribe. A banner that leaves the page usable isn’t a wall, whatever else it does. These lines and severities are PeekWell’s own, drawn from the decisions listed below.
Other checks cover the rest of the banner. EU-03 compares how hard it is to refuse and to accept, and EU-01 records what loads before anyone answers. The UK version, under PECR and the ICO’s guidance, is UK-03.
The scan has limits, and the report says so. It sees the public pages it visited, and the members area when you give it a sign-in. It doesn’t port-scan, try to get in where it isn’t allowed, run any security test or open addresses nobody linked to. It sees the wall as a first-time visitor from the scan’s own country, so a wall shown only elsewhere may not appear. A Passed means the expected behaviour was observed on the pages scanned. It doesn’t say the site complies.
Why it matters for a company
A wall is easy to see from outside, and two Spanish files show how plainly a regulator records one. In the Iberia case, a visitor complained in October 2019 that the airline’s site gave no way to refuse cookies. When the AEPD checked in early 2020, the site still wouldn’t let anyone carry on without clicking Accept or opening the settings. The AEPD fined Iberia €30,000. In a file closed in 2025, the AEPD looked at edatv.news, a news site. Its first screen offered “Aceptar y cerrar” or “Rechazar y pagar”, and the second meant registering and giving card details. That fine, €1,200 after reductions, was for having no way to change a choice later, but the wall is written into the findings.
The pay-or-OK decisions listed here turned on what the Accept button covered, not on the price. Austria’s DSB accepted a subscription as an alternative for derStandard.at in 2023, then found the consent invalid because it lumped analytics and social media plugins in with advertising. The Federal Administrative Court upheld that finding in August 2025 and allowed a further appeal on the point of law. We found no ruling on that appeal as of 4 November 2026, so the line could still move. Lower Saxony reprimanded heise.de for the same reason, and the Danish authority told Jysk Fynske Medier that statistics can’t ride along with marketing. None of them ended in a fine. Each one found the consent wasn’t valid.
The bill arrives in another check. Every cookie set on the strength of an invalid Accept counts as set without consent, which is the situation EU-01 describes.
Smaller companies and larger companies
The rule has no size threshold. A wall on a local shop’s site is judged on the same screen as one on a national newspaper.
In a smaller company a wall is usually a setting. Many consent tools and themes have an option that blocks the page until the visitor answers, and with Reject switched off it becomes a wall. A news or content site may also add a ready-made pay option from an outside provider, as edatv.news did, without changing what Accept covers.
In a larger company a wall is usually a business decision, made to protect advertising income. The decided cases are publishers that chose pay or OK and then asked for one blanket consent in exchange for free reading. The regulators accepted the model in principle each time and found the bundle was the problem. Larger sites also embed video players, live blogs and social posts, and the Berlingske case shows that blocking those until consent counts as a wall too.
Enforcement cases
Published decisions about other companies, listed for context. Each links to the authority's own page. They say nothing about any particular website.

Larger companies
Iberia Líneas Aéreas de España
A visitor complained that the airline's site said cookies had to be accepted to keep browsing. AEPD inspectors found in January and February 2020 that unless a visitor clicked Accept or Cookie settings, the site would not let them carry on, so there was no way to refuse. The settings page allowed choices one by one but no refusal of everything at once, and cookies loaded as soon as the home page opened. The fine was set under Article 22.2 of the Spanish e-commerce law (LSSI).
Read the AEPD (Spain) publication about Iberia Líneas Aéreas de EspañaPublishers of derStandard.at (pseudonymised in the published decisions; named by the complainant's organisation, noyb)
A reader met a wall offering two options, read on with advertising or take a paid subscription, and clicked Agree. The authority accepted that a subscription can in principle be an alternative to consent. It found that the publishers could not explain why the consent also had to cover analytics cookies, site optimisation and social media plugins as well as advertising and ad measurement, so the blanket consent was not granular and not valid. On 13 August 2025 the Federal Administrative Court dismissed the publishers' appeal against that finding and allowed a further appeal on a point of law.
Read the Datenschutzbehörde (Austria), upheld by the Federal Administrative Court in 2025 publication about Publishers of derStandard.at (pseudonymised in the published decisions; named by the complainant's organisation, noyb)Heise Medien GmbH & Co. KG (heise.de)
Visitors could read heise.de for free by clicking Accept, or take a paid Pur subscription without tracking. The authority accepted that subscribers and consenting readers got the same articles. It found that one Accept click gave a blanket consent to 17 purposes, among them personalised content and product development, with no choice by purpose or by vendor, so no valid consent was obtained. It issued a reprimand on 17 May 2023.
Read the Landesbeauftragte für den Datenschutz Niedersachsen (Germany) publication about Heise Medien GmbH & Co. KG (heise.de)Jysk Fynske Medier P/S (jv.dk)
Visitors to jv.dk could consent to statistics and marketing cookies and read the unlocked articles, or pay for access to everything. The authority accepted the model in principle, but found that consenting visitors got less than subscribers and that the publisher had not shown statistics tracking was a necessary part of the alternative to paying. In March 2024 it refused to reopen the case, holding that only the marketing purpose can be tied to the paid alternative.
Read the Datatilsynet (Denmark) publication about Jysk Fynske Medier P/S (jv.dk)Berlingske Media A/S (berlingske.dk)
Embedded content in articles, such as video players and live blogs, stayed blocked unless visitors consented to statistics and marketing cookies. The authority treated this partial wall like a full one and found the consent was not freely given. In January 2025 it found the order met, because visitors who refuse can now reach embedded content substantially equivalent to what consenting visitors get.
Read the Datatilsynet (Denmark) publication about Berlingske Media A/S (berlingske.dk)
Smaller companies
EDA TV Consulting, S.L. (edatv.news)
AEPD inspectors found that the banner's only way to refuse non-technical cookies was a button labelled Reject and pay, which opened a form asking for an email address, a phone number and card details for a monthly subscription run by an outside provider. The fine itself was for having no way to change a choice once given. The decision records the pay wall but does not rule on it.
Read the AEPD (Spain) publication about EDA TV Consulting, S.L. (edatv.news)
How to fix it
- Look at the page as a stranger. Open a private window, don’t touch the banner, and try to scroll and click. If nothing moves, you have a wall.
- Switch off “block until consent” in your consent tool. Most tools have the setting under the banner’s behaviour. Let the page load behind the banner, with the optional tags held off.
- Give visitors a way in that isn’t Accept. Put Reject all or “Continue without accepting” on the first screen, and make sure it opens the content. EU-03 covers how the two buttons should compare.
- If you run pay or OK, narrow what Accept covers. Limit it to the purposes the payment replaces, usually advertising, and let visitors refuse analytics, social media and personalisation one by one in the settings.
- Keep the paid version clean, and write down why it’s fair. Subscribers shouldn’t get trackers that need consent. Note your reasoning on the price and on why the paid version is equivalent, as the CNIL and the German regulators ask.
- Check embedded content. If videos or social posts stay blocked for visitors who refuse, offer the same content another way, as Berlingske eventually did.
- Re-scan. Clear cookies and storage, reload, and run a scan again. The finding should clear once the content opens without Accept.
Whether a particular pay-or-OK model gives valid consent in a given country is a question for your legal adviser. Peeky reports what the page let a visitor do.
Questions
Are cookie walls allowed under the GDPR?
Not as a bare take-it-or-leave-it. The EDPB's consent guidelines say access to a service must not depend on accepting cookies. Their example is a page hidden behind an Accept cookies button, and they say consent given that way isn't free.
A wall with a real way past it is a different case. Several national regulators accept an alternative the visitor pays for, on conditions.
What does pay or OK mean?
It's a wall with two doors: accept tracking and read for free, or pay and read without it. The French, German, Spanish, Danish and Austrian regulators accept it in principle. Between them they ask for a fair price, an equivalent paid version and a consent limited to what the payment replaces.
The EDPB's only adopted text on it, Opinion 08/2024, covers large online platforms. Its general guidelines on consent or pay hadn't been adopted by November 2026.
Can I make visitors pay if they refuse cookies?
Some regulators allow it. The AEPD's cookie guide says the alternative to consent need not be free, but it has to be genuinely equivalent and offered by the publisher itself. The CNIL asks for a reasonable price and says the paid version shouldn't set any tracker that needs consent.
The decided cases rejected an Accept button that bundled analytics, social media or personalisation with the advertising the payment replaces.
Is a cookie wall the same as a paywall?
No. A paywall asks everyone to pay for the content. A cookie wall makes accepting cookies the price of getting in, sometimes with payment as the only other option.
A site can have both, for example free articles behind a consent request and premium articles behind a subscription. EU-23 only looks at the consent part.
How does Peeky test for a cookie wall?
Peeky opens your pages as a first-time visitor and never clicks Accept to get in. It checks whether a consent layer covers the content, stops the page scrolling or catches clicks meant for the page, and whether any button other than Accept leads to the content.
For a pay-or-accept wall it reads what the Accept button covers. How a scan works has the full path.
Filed with
The rule
GDPR (Regulation (EU) 2016/679), Arts. 4(11) and 7(4), recital 43
Read the rule (GDPR (Regulation (EU) 2016/679), Arts. 4(11) and 7(4), recital 43)Sources
The law
- Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR), Official Journal L 119
- Directive 2009/136/EC, Official Journal L 337, Art. 2(5) (replaces Art. 5(3) of Directive 2002/58/EC)
- Directive 2002/58/EC (ePrivacy Directive), original text, recital 25
Guidance
- EDPB, Guidelines 05/2020 on consent under Regulation 2016/679, version 1.1, adopted 4 May 2020 (paras. 37 to 41 on conditional services and cookie walls)
- EDPB, Report of the work undertaken by the Cookie Banner Taskforce, adopted 17 January 2023
- EDPB, Opinion 08/2024 on valid consent in the context of consent or pay models implemented by large online platforms, adopted 17 April 2024
- EDPB, Work programme 2026-2027 (12 February 2026): the EDPB is working on guidelines on consent or pay
- Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens (Netherlands), Websites moeten toegankelijk blijven bij weigeren tracking cookies (7 March 2019)
- CNIL, Cookie walls: la CNIL publie des premiers critères d'évaluation (16 May 2022)
- Datenschutzkonferenz (Germany), Beschluss of 22 March 2023: Bewertung von Pur-Abo-Modellen auf Websites
- AEPD (Spain), Guía sobre el uso de las cookies, updated May 2024 (section 3.2.10 on refusing access)
- Garante per la protezione dei dati personali, Linee guida cookie e altri strumenti di tracciamento, 10 June 2021 (section 6.1 on cookie walls)
Decisions and cases
- AEPD (Spain), resolution in procedure PS/00032/2020 (Iberia Líneas Aéreas de España)
- AEPD (Spain), resolution ending procedure PS/00444/2024 (EXP202414147) on voluntary payment (EDA TV Consulting, S.L.)
- Datenschutzbehörde (Austria), decision 2023-0.174.027 of 29 March 2023 on consent or subscription on a news portal (pseudonymised, in German)
- Bundesverwaltungsgericht (Austria), Erkenntnis of 13 August 2025, W291 2272970-1 (appeal on the news portal decision, in German)
- Landesbeauftragte für den Datenschutz Niedersachsen, reprimand to Heise Medien GmbH & Co. KG of 17 May 2023 (redacted copy published by noyb, in German)
- Datatilsynet (Denmark), Jysk Fynske Mediers brug af cookie walls, decision of 8 February 2023 (in Danish)
- Datatilsynet (Denmark), Cookie walls: statistics was not a necessary part of the alternative to paid access (JFM and GulogGratis, March 2024, in Danish)
- Datatilsynet (Denmark), Invalid consent in cookie walls on berlingske.dk, order of 14 February 2024 (in Danish)
- Datatilsynet (Denmark), Berlingske complies with the order in the cookie wall case, decision of 17 January 2025 (in Danish)
Further reading
- Conseil d'État (France), decision of 19 June 2020, no. 434684 (CNIL cookie guidelines: no general ban on cookie walls by soft law)
- Court of Justice of the European Union, judgment of 4 July 2023, Case C-252/21 Meta Platforms and Others (para. 150)
- noyb, Court decides Pay or Okay on DerStandard.at is illegal (18 August 2025)
Last checked against the source:
For information only. Not legal advice.
