Skip to content
PeekWellThe Handbook
Join now

Pre-ticked boxes in UK cookie banners: what PECR allows

At a glance

UK-19HighPECR reg. 6 and Sch. A1 paras. 2, 5 and 6 (DUAA 2025 s. 112 and Sch. 12); UK GDPR Art. 4(11) and recital 32; ICO guidance on storage and access technologies (29 April 2026)

Peeky reads your cookie settings before touching a switch. Advertising and tracking must start off; a statistics switch may start on only within the 2026 rules.

Last checked against the source:

I need to fix thisI need the rule

The rule

Since 5 February 2026, regulation 6(1) of PECR reads: “Subject to Schedule A1, a person must not store information, or gain access to information stored, in the terminal equipment of a subscriber or user.” The main way through is paragraph 2 of Schedule A1: the person must be “provided with clear and comprehensive information about the purpose of the storage or access” and must give “consent to the storage or access”.

PECR takes its meaning of consent from the UK GDPR, and the UK GDPR is explicit about boxes that come ticked.

Article 4(11) defines consent as a “freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous indication of the data subject’s wishes by which he or she, by a statement or by a clear affirmative action, signifies agreement”. Recital 32 says ticking a box on a website can be consent, then rules out the opposite: “Silence, pre-ticked boxes or inactivity should not therefore constitute consent.”

The ICO’s guidance on storage and access technologies, finalised on 29 April 2026, applies that to cookie banners. Consent needs “a clear and positive action”: continuing to use a website “does not constitute valid consent, nor does the use of a pre-ticked box or equivalent”.

The guidance asks “Can we pre-enable any non-exempt storage and access technologies?” and answers: “No. You must not pre-enable non-exempt storage and access technologies. This is the case even when: you think that subscribers and users may be unlikely to agree to them otherwise; or you don’t think that the technology is that privacy intrusive.”

Before the guidance was final, the ICO had already said it in one line. Its template letter to websites of 21 November 2024 told them “you cannot use any pre-ticked boxes (or equivalents such as ‘on’ sliders) for non-essential cookies”.

Since February 2026, though, UK law has an opening written into the text itself. The Data (Use and Access) Act 2025 added two exceptions to Schedule A1 that work on objection rather than consent.

Paragraph 5 covers storage whose “sole purpose” is to collect information “for statistical purposes about how the service is used with a view to making improvements to the service”, or to the website. The information can’t be shared except to help with those improvements, the visitor must get “clear and comprehensive information about the purpose”, and the visitor must be “given a simple means of objecting, free of charge, to the storage or access and does not object”. Paragraph 6 does the same for storage whose sole purpose is to let “the way the website appears or functions” adapt “to the preferences of the subscriber or user”.

The ICO spells out what that means for the settings screen. The objection route can sit in your existing consent tool, “by having your ‘statistical purposes’ or ‘appearance’ toggles on by default, with the ability for users to change them to off at any time.” The example it points to shows a customise layer where “the ‘analytics’ category is on by default” and social media tracking and advertising are off. Once someone objects, you “must stop storing or accessing information on their device”.

The opening is narrow. The ICO says the statistics exception “is not for identifying, tracking or monitoring people or groups of people who use your service. It also doesn’t apply to things like online advertising.” The appearance exception doesn’t cover choosing content from a visitor’s known or inferred interests, which needs consent. So advertising, social media, personalisation and session recording still have to start off.

On the penalty side, Schedule 13 of the 2025 Act applies the higher maximum of the Data Protection Act 2018 to regulation 6: for an undertaking, £17,500,000 or 4% of total annual worldwide turnover, whichever is higher. We found no ICO decision on pre-ticked cookie options as of 4 November 2026, from the ICO or from the Information Commission (ICO), which took over the ICO’s functions on 30 September 2026. The checks the ICO described in its November 2024 letters covered advertising cookies set before consent, refusing as easily as accepting, and advertising cookies set without consent. None of them looked at the settings layer.

The EU’s Court of Justice reached the same answer as recital 32 in Planet49 on 1 October 2019, before the UK left the EU: a pre-checked box the user has to untick isn’t valid consent to cookies.

What PeekWell checks and how

UK-19 asks one question: is any cookie option that needs consent switched on before the visitor chooses? It’s pass or fail.

The scan is automated and works the same way as EU-21. It opens your public pages as a first-time visitor, opens the banner’s settings layer from the first screen and reads every switch and box before touching any, including vendor lists the layer links to. It takes a screenshot of the layer as it opened. The check fails on any of three things:

  1. A non-essential option starts on. Advertising, marketing, personalisation, social media and session recording count, and so do analytics, statistics, performance and “functional” options unless the UK exception below applies. A strictly necessary category shown as on and locked is expected.
  2. Saving the untouched layer does more than refusing. The scan presses Save or Confirm my choices without changing anything, reloads, visits two more pages and compares what it sees with the run where it pressed Reject all. Any extra cookie, storage or request that needs consent fails, and so does consent stored for such a purpose or vendor.
  3. The first screen only offers a pre-selected bundle. If, besides accepting, the first screen’s only control saves a pre-selected set (“Save”, “Confirm my choices”, “OK”) that includes purposes needing consent, the check fails.

On pages that run the IAB framework, the scan also reads the framework’s consent data before anything is chosen. Consent recorded at that point for a purpose or vendor that needs it counts as a switch that starts on.

Here’s the UK difference. A statistics switch, or one for how the site looks or works, may start on. It passes when the tool behind it meets every condition UK-01 checks for those exceptions: it only counts how the site is used, with no advertising use and no recordings of individual visits; it doesn’t fingerprint the visitor; the banner or a page it links to says what’s collected and why; there’s a free, simple way to object; and once someone objects, it stops. The scan decides that from the same captures. Advertising, social media, personalisation and session recording never pass by starting on.

The check passes when everything that needs consent starts off, any switch that starts on meets those conditions, and saving the untouched layer gives the same result as Reject all. A banner with no settings layer has nothing pre-set, so it can’t fail the first two. Where the line falls is PeekWell’s own reading of the rules above, and the finding shows the screenshot and the before and after.

Switches labelled legitimate interest, or “object”, belong to UK-20, and whether refusing is as easy as accepting is UK-02.

With no banner at all, or a banner with no way to refuse, the answer depends on what the site does. If anything non-exempt is stored or sent on any run, the check fails at the same severity. If nothing non-exempt shows up at all, it passes, and the finding says which runs showed that.

The scan has limits, and the report says so. It reads the settings layer of the public banner as a first-time visitor sees it. Pre-selected options inside an app, in a sign-up flow behind a login you didn’t share, or on a newsletter form are outside this check. Whether a third-party analytics provider acts only as your processor sits in your contract, and the scan doesn’t read contracts. It doesn’t port-scan, try to get in where it isn’t allowed, run any security test or open addresses nobody linked to. A Passed means the expected behaviour was observed on the pages scanned. It doesn’t say the site complies.

Why it matters for a company

The ICO’s position leaves little room. Its guidance rules out pre-enabling even where you think visitors would refuse otherwise, or where you think the technology isn’t very intrusive. And a settings screen is something anyone can open and read from outside, the ICO included.

The 2026 exceptions make this easier to get wrong. A switch labelled statistics that starts on looks just like the ICO’s own example. If the tool behind it also feeds an advertising platform, records sessions or is shared beyond helping you improve the site, it isn’t covered, and the switch is a pre-ticked box after all.

No UK authority has published a decision on this practice yet, so the decisions listed here are EU ones, for comparison. The clearest is the Dutch Kruidvat case. A slider in the third step of the cookie flow on kruidvat.nl was set to advertising cookies by default, and a visitor who went through without changing anything was recorded as agreeing. The Dutch authority fined A.S. Watson €600,000 in May 2024 and set the fine at €50,000 on objection in May 2025, keeping its finding. The Spanish Freshly Cosmetics file adds the other half: behind Personalizar every group started as accepted, and unticking them didn’t stop cookies that weren’t needed.

There’s also the plain consequence. Data sent to an advertising partner because a switch started on has already gone, and fixing the default later doesn’t recall it.

Smaller companies and larger companies

PECR has no size threshold. The same switch decides it for a sole trader and a listed group.

In a smaller company the banner usually comes from a plugin or a hosted builder. Some tools ship with an analytics category switched on, which can now be fine in the UK if the analytics is simple first-party counting. The catch is that a “statistics” or “performance” category often holds more than that: an analytics setup linked to an ad account, or a pixel someone filed under the wrong heading. The Italian Sotto il cavolo case shows how far an unchanged default can go, with six boxes pre-ticked, Facebook and YouTube among them.

In a larger company the settings layer is longer and has more owners. Vendor lists run to hundreds of names, and one default can switch on all of them. Many larger sites also serve the UK and the EU from one banner. The UK rules allow a statistics switch to start on; EU-21 doesn’t, so a banner built to the UK line can still fail it for European visitors.

Enforcement cases

Published decisions about other companies, listed for context. Each links to the authority's own page. They say nothing about any particular website.

The Officer, squinting at a file.

Larger companies

Smaller companies

How to fix it

The aim is a settings layer where nothing that needs consent starts on, and an untouched Save means no.

  1. Look at the settings as a visitor. Open your site in a private window, open the banner’s settings and write down every switch or box that’s already on, including in any vendor list.
  2. Switch advertising, social media, personalisation and recording off by default. In most consent tools this is a default-state setting per category or vendor.
  3. Keep a statistics switch on only if it qualifies. It has to count how your own site is used, with the data shared only to help you improve it. The banner has to say so, and switching it off has to stop the tool on that visit and the next pages. If any of that isn’t true, start it off.
  4. Keep an appearance switch for appearance. Remembering a language or a layout fits. Choosing what content to show from a visitor’s interests doesn’t.
  5. Make an untouched Save store a refusal. Press Save without changing anything and check the network tab and the cookies. Nothing that needs consent should load.
  6. If one banner serves the UK and the EU, check both. PeekWell’s EU check, EU-21, expects every non-essential switch off for EU visitors, statistics included.
  7. Re-scan. Clear cookies and storage, reload and run a scan again. The finding should show nothing that needs consent switched on before a choice.

Whether a given setup meets the exceptions is a question for your legal adviser. Peeky reports the switches it saw and what Save did.

Questions

Are pre-ticked boxes allowed in the UK?

Not as consent. Recital 32 of the UK GDPR says pre-ticked boxes don't count, and the ICO's guidance says a pre-ticked box "or equivalent" isn't valid consent for cookies. That covers advertising, social media and most tracking.

Since February 2026 there's one narrow opening: a switch for simple site statistics or for how the site looks may start on, if the visitor is told and can switch it off.

Are UK cookies opt-in or opt-out?

Mostly opt-in. Advertising, social media tracking and anything that follows people around need a yes first.

Two kinds can now run on an opt-out: statistics used only to improve your own site, and storage that adapts how the site looks or works to the visitor's preferences. Both need clear information and a free, simple way to object, and they have to stop when someone does.

Can the analytics switch in my cookie settings start on?

In the UK, sometimes. The ICO says you could have your "statistical purposes" toggles on by default, with the ability to switch them off at any time. Its own example shows analytics on and advertising and social media tracking off.

The exception is narrow. It doesn't cover analytics used for advertising or for tracking individual people, and PeekWell's EU check expects that switch off for EU visitors.

Does a slider set to on count as a pre-ticked box?

Yes. The ICO's guidance talks about a pre-ticked box "or equivalent", and its November 2024 letters to websites said "you cannot use any pre-ticked boxes (or equivalents such as 'on' sliders) for non-essential cookies". A toggle, slider or vendor switch that starts on counts the same way.

Does the Planet49 ruling apply in the UK?

In effect, yes. Planet49 was decided by the EU Court of Justice in October 2019, before the UK left the EU. It held that a pre-ticked box the user has to untick isn't valid consent to cookies. UK law says the same in its own words: recital 32 of the UK GDPR rules out pre-ticked boxes, and the ICO's guidance repeats it.

Peeky checks it on your public pages by reading every switch before touching any. How a scan works has the full path.

Filed with

The rule

Privacy and Electronic Communications (EC Directive) Regulations 2003 (PECR), reg. 6, as substituted by the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025, s. 112

Read the rule (Privacy and Electronic Communications (EC Directive) Regulations 2003 (PECR), reg. 6, as substituted by the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025, s. 112)

A case

A.S. Watson Health & Beauty Continental Europe B.V. (Kruidvat.nl)

Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens (Netherlands, EU data protection authority), 2024

Read the decision (A.S. Watson Health & Beauty Continental Europe B.V. (Kruidvat.nl))

Your site

Is your website affected? Join now to find out.

Join now

Sources

The law

  1. PECR 2003, regulation 6 (as substituted 5 February 2026), legislation.gov.uk
  2. PECR 2003, Schedule A1 (storage and access exceptions, paras. 2, 5 and 6), legislation.gov.uk
  3. Data (Use and Access) Act 2025, Schedule 12 (inserts PECR Schedule A1), in force 5 February 2026
  4. Data (Use and Access) Act 2025, Schedule 13 (PECR enforcement; higher maximum penalty for regulation 6)
  5. Data Protection Act 2018, section 157 (maximum amount of penalty)
  6. UK GDPR, Article 4 (definitions, including consent in Art. 4(11))
  7. UK GDPR, recitals (recital 32: silence, pre-ticked boxes or inactivity are not consent)
  8. The Data (Use and Access) Act 2025 (Commencement No. 6 and Transitional and Saving Provisions) Regulations 2026 (SI 2026/82)
  9. The Data (Use and Access) Act 2025 (Commencement No. 9 and Transitional and Saving Provisions) Regulations 2026 (SI 2026/1015): the Information Commission takes over the Information Commissioner's functions on 30 September 2026

Guidance

  1. ICO, Guidance on the use of storage and access technologies (finalised 29 April 2026)
  2. ICO, Guidance on the use of storage and access technologies: What are the PECR rules? (a pre-ticked box or equivalent is not consent)
  3. ICO, Guidance on the use of storage and access technologies: How do we comply with the PECR rules? (Can we pre-enable any non-exempt storage and access technologies?)
  4. ICO, Guidance on the use of storage and access technologies: What are the exceptions? (statistics and appearance toggles on by default)
  5. ICO, Guidance on the use of storage and access technologies: How do we manage consent in practice? (good and bad practice examples)
  6. ICO, Cookie letters project phase 2: template letter to websites (21 November 2024)

Decisions and cases

  1. Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens (Netherlands), fine decision on A.S. Watson (Kruidvat.nl), 2 May 2024, in Dutch
  2. Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens (Netherlands), decision on objection, A.S. Watson (Kruidvat.nl), 27 May 2025, in Dutch
  3. AEPD (Spain), procedure PS/00315/2022 (EXP202206594), Freshly Cosmetics, S.L., ended by voluntary payment, in Spanish
  4. APD / GBA (Belgium), Litigation Chamber, decision on the merits 12/2019 of 17 December 2019, in French
  5. Garante per la protezione dei dati personali, Provvedimento del 17 ottobre 2024 [10091178] (Sotto il cavolo s.n.c.)

Further reading

  1. Court of Justice of the EU, judgment of 1 October 2019, Case C-673/17 Planet49 (ECLI:EU:C:2019:801)
  2. Court of Justice of the EU, press release 125/19 on Case C-673/17 Planet49 (1 October 2019)

Last checked against the source:

For information only. Not legal advice.