
Legitimate interest vs consent: UK cookies after Reject all
At a glance
UK-20MediumPECR reg. 6 and Sch. A1 (DUAA 2025 s. 112 and Sch. 12); UK GDPR Arts. 6(1)(f) and 21; ICO guidance on storage and access technologies (29 April 2026); ICO update report into adtech and real time bidding (2019)
Peeky clicks Reject all on a UK site, then checks whether anything stays on under legitimate interest, so a visitor would have to object as a second step.
Last checked against the source:
The rule
Since 5 February 2026, regulation 6(1) of PECR reads: “Subject to Schedule A1, a person must not store information, or gain access to information stored, in the terminal equipment of a subscriber or user.” Section 112 of the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025 (DUAA) substituted the regulation.
Schedule A1 lists every case where storage or access is allowed: consent (para. 2), carrying a communication (para. 3), what is strictly necessary for a service the person asked for (para. 4), statistics about how a service or website is used (para. 5), adapting how a website looks or works to the person’s preferences (para. 6), and emergency assistance (para. 7). Legitimate interest isn’t on the list. The statistics and appearance exceptions work on objection rather than consent: each applies only where the person “is given a simple means of objecting, free of charge, to the storage or access and does not object”.
Legitimate interest belongs to the UK GDPR. Article 6(1)(f) allows processing that is necessary for “the legitimate interests pursued by the controller or by a third party”, unless people’s interests or rights override them, and Article 21 lets people object to it. That covers what a company does with personal data, but the question of whether something may go on the device is PECR’s, and PECR comes first.
The ICO’s guidance on storage and access technologies, finalised in April 2026, sets out how the two laws fit together.
The guidance says that “if regulation 6 applies, the full range of lawful bases under the UK GDPR are not always available to you.” Where you need consent for the storage or access and the information is personal data, “you should use consent as your lawful basis under the UK GDPR for subsequent processing”. Trying to apply legitimate interests as well “is entirely unnecessary. It may also render your original consent request invalid.” The guidance sees “an element of unfairness” where people think their data rests on consent, “yet once they withdraw consent, you continue to process via legitimate interests”, and it says: “You must not retrospectively use the legitimate interests lawful basis to justify processing in cases where you encounter problems with the validity of consent.”
The guidance is firm on advertising. “The use of storage and access technologies for online advertising purposes requires consent”, both for selecting and delivering ads and for any tracking and profiling that goes with them. The exceptions page adds: “Online advertising purposes are not exempt from PECR’s consent requirements and never have been.” The ICO’s checklist for consent tools includes “Our consent mechanism does not incorrectly use legitimate interests as a lawful basis”, and its bad-practice example shows “legitimate interests” toggles switched on by default beside consent toggles switched off.
The ICO took the same view of the advertising industry in its update report into adtech and real time bidding of 20 June 2019. It found that the nature of the processing “makes it impossible to meet the legitimate interests lawful basis requirements”, so that “legitimate interests cannot be used for the main bid request processing”, and that the only lawful basis for that processing is consent, covering “the placing and reading of the cookie and the onward transfer of the bid request”.
The UK’s statistics and appearance exceptions add one wrinkle. The ICO says the simple means of objecting can come through your consent tool, “by having your ‘statistical purposes’ or ‘appearance’ toggles on by default, with the ability for users to change them to off at any time”. The statistics exception “is not for identifying, tracking or monitoring people”, and it doesn’t apply to online advertising. So an object switch is the law’s own route for genuine first-party statistics, and never one for advertising.
Legitimate-interest switches are built into IAB Europe’s Transparency and Consent Framework (TCF), which many consent tools support. Version 2.2, in place from 20 November 2023, took legitimate interest away from purposes 3 to 6, the profiling and personalised ads and content purposes. It left it available for purposes 2 and 7 to 11, such as choosing ads from limited data and measuring ad performance, and it keeps publishers’ own purposes outside its policies.
Penalties changed on 5 February 2026 as well. DUAA Schedule 13 applies the Data Protection Act 2018’s penalty rules to PECR, and for regulation 6 the higher maximum applies: for an undertaking, “£17,500,000 or 4% of the undertaking’s total annual worldwide turnover in the preceding financial year, whichever is higher” (s. 157(5)). That’s the most the law allows, and it says nothing about what any one case would cost. We haven’t found a published UK decision on a legitimate-interest layer in a cookie banner, from the ICO or from the Information Commission (ICO), which took over the ICO’s functions on 30 September 2026.
What PeekWell checks and how
UK-20 asks one question: after a visitor clicks Reject all, is anything still switched on under legitimate interest, so that saying no takes a second step? It’s the same question as EU-22, with the UK’s two objection-based exceptions allowed for.
The scan is automated. It opens your public pages the way a first-time visitor’s browser would and clicks Reject all. On another run it accepts, then reopens the cookie settings and takes the consent back. After each refusal it reads three things:
- The framework’s record. On pages that run the IAB framework, it listens for the consent tool’s update through the framework’s public interface, the
addEventListenercall that TCF 2.2 requires every consent tool to answer, and decodes the TC string as a cross-check. It’s a finding if any purpose from 2 or 7 to 11, any vendor or the publisher is still marked on by legitimate interest, or if there’s any legitimate interest at all for purposes 1 or 3 to 6, which the framework itself no longer allows. - The settings and vendor lists. It opens the settings layer and every vendor list and reads each switch. A legitimate-interest or “object” switch still on after the refusal is a finding.
- The banner’s words. If the banner or its settings give legitimate interest as the basis for storing or reading information on the device, or for advertising, profiling, personalisation or audience measurement, with an objection step apart from the refusal, that’s a finding too. When the wording is the only evidence, the report marks the finding as AI-assisted, because reading text takes judgement.
The UK exception works like this. An object switch for statistics (Sch. A1 para. 5) or for how the site looks or works (para. 6) isn’t a finding when the tool behind it meets every condition UK-01 lists for those exceptions, and as long as Reject all switches it off too. A switch that stays on after Reject all, or one covering advertising, is a finding.
The framework’s special purposes, such as security and fraud prevention, carry no signal a visitor can switch off, and the scan doesn’t count them. Legitimate interest named only in your privacy notice, for processing that stores nothing on the device and reads nothing from it, isn’t what this check looks for.
Two other checks sit next to this one. Consent switches that start on before anyone chooses are UK-19. Trackers that keep loading after Reject all are UK-04, and UK-20 leaves them to it.
A site with no banner, or no way to refuse, still gets an answer. If any run records non-essential storage, UK-20 is a finding, because there’s no refusal a visitor could make. If nothing non-essential shows up at all, the check passes and says which runs showed that.
The scan has limits, and the report says so. It sees the public pages it visited, and the members area when you give it a sign-in. It doesn’t port-scan, try to get in where it isn’t allowed, run any security test or open addresses nobody linked to. A legitimate-interest signal shows what your consent tool tells vendors they may do. Whether a vendor then processes data on its own servers can’t be seen from a browser. A Passed means the expected behaviour was observed on the pages scanned. It doesn’t say the site complies.
Why it matters for a company
The bigger risk in the ICO’s guidance is to the consent you already hold. Adding legitimate interest on top of it “may also render your original consent request invalid”. So a banner that collects a yes for advertising and keeps legitimate interest in reserve can weaken the yes it did get. And on the ICO’s reading, consent is the only basis open for advertising cookies, so a legitimate-interest switch for them has nothing to fall back on.
There’s no UK decision on this design yet, so the clearest examples come from the EU, decided under EU law and shown here for comparison. Sweden’s IMY reprimanded Aller Media AB on 28 April 2025 over its banner on recept.se as it stood in May 2021. To refuse all processing, “a data subject first had to refuse consent and then go ahead and find the option to object to processing for certain purposes”, in the words of the English translation the EDPB published. The company said its consent platform provider had recommended both bases; IMY held the company responsible anyway. Spain’s AEPD fined Chatwith.io Worldwide, S.L. €5,000 for a vendor list where more than half of about 130 vendors had legitimate interest ticked by default, with objection possible only one vendor at a time and no button to object to everything.
Smaller companies and larger companies
PECR regulation 6 has no size threshold. What differs is how the second step ends up on the banner.
In a smaller company the banner usually comes from a consent tool set up once and left on its defaults. Switching on the IAB setup brings a long vendor list, often with legitimate interest pre-set. The UK twist is that some switches are fine: a statistics switch that starts on can meet the exception, so the work is telling that one apart from the advertising ones. The Aller decision is a reminder that following a consent tool provider’s advice doesn’t move the responsibility.
In a larger company, legitimate interest tends to come with advertising revenue. A publisher selling ads through the framework can claim it for its own purposes, and partners for measurement. That’s the processing the ICO’s 2019 report looked at, and its answer for the bid request was consent.
Enforcement cases
Published decisions about other companies, listed for context. Each links to the authority's own page. They say nothing about any particular website.

Larger companies
Aller Media AB (recept.se)
Decided under EU law and shown here for comparison. IMY examined the cookie banner on recept.se as it was on 21 May 2021. The first layer said visitors could object where legitimate interest was used but offered no way to do it there; to refuse all processing, a visitor had to refuse consent and then find the option to object. The company said its consent platform provider had recommended using both consent and legitimate interest. IMY found it had not shown a legitimate interest, held that a supplier's advice does not shift that responsibility, and issued a reprimand.
Read the IMY (Sweden, EU data protection authority) publication about Aller Media AB (recept.se)IAB Europe (Transparency and Consent Framework)
Decided under EU law and shown here for comparison. The Belgian authority found that the framework many UK and EU sites use processes personal data through the TC string, and that the legal grounds it offered for adtech vendors' later processing were inadequate. Its orders included a ban on legitimate interest as a basis for processing by the organisations taking part. In May 2025 the Market Court annulled the decision on procedural grounds, endorsed the authority's reasoning and confirmed the fine.
Read the APD (Belgium, EU data protection authority) publication about IAB Europe (Transparency and Consent Framework)
Smaller companies
Chatwith.io Worldwide, S.L.
Decided under EU law and shown here for comparison. On the company's website, where lawyers advertise, more than half of about 130 vendors in the consent tool's vendor list had the legitimate-interest box ticked by default, and a visitor could only object one vendor at a time. There was an Accept all button but nothing to reject or object to everything. The AEPD treated this as a deceptive design and fined €5,000 for it under GDPR Art. 5(1)(a), with €2,000 for the privacy notice and €5,000 under Spain's cookie law. It did not decide whether the legitimate interests themselves could be justified.
Read the AEPD (Spain, EU data protection authority) publication about Chatwith.io Worldwide, S.L.
How to fix it
In the UK the fix has one extra judgement in it: which switches the law lets you keep. The steps below fit most consent tools.
- Refuse, then look. Open the site in a private window, click Reject all, then open the settings and the vendor or partner list. Any switch still on under “legitimate interest” or “object” is what a scan will report. On a site that runs the TCF, a developer can check the record in the browser console with
__tcfapi('addEventListener', 2, callback)and readpurpose.legitimateInterests,vendor.legitimateInterestsandpublisher.legitimateInterestsonceeventStatusisuseractioncomplete. - Turn legitimate interest off for advertising and tracking. In the consent tool’s IAB settings, remove legitimate interest for purposes and vendors, or set publisher restrictions: “require consent” for vendors that registered a purpose as flexible, “not allowed” for the rest.
- Keep only the switches the law allows. A statistics or appearance switch may start on if the tool meets the conditions in UK-01. In the banner, call it a statistics or appearance setting.
- Make Reject all clear everything. One click should turn off every switch, the statistics and appearance ones included. Then check the same after withdrawing consent through the settings link.
- Fix the words. Take “legitimate interest” out of the banner wherever it describes cookies, advertising, profiling, personalisation or audience measurement.
- Re-scan. Clear cookies and storage, reload, and run a scan again. The finding should go once Reject all leaves nothing on.
Whether a particular use of data can rest on legitimate interest is a question for your legal adviser. Peeky reports what the banner recorded and what it said.
Questions
Legitimate interest vs consent: which one applies to cookies in the UK?
Consent, for anything that isn't exempt. PECR regulation 6 decides whether you may store or read something on a visitor's device, and none of its exceptions is legitimate interest. The ICO adds that where the cookie needs consent, consent should also be the basis for what you do with the data afterwards.
What is legitimate interest, and where does it still fit?
It's one of the UK GDPR's lawful bases: processing a company needs for a genuine purpose, as long as people's interests don't override it. It still fits processing that stores nothing on a visitor's device and reads nothing from it, such as fraud checks on your own server. It can't stand in for consent to cookies or similar tracking.
Do the new recognised legitimate interests cover cookies?
No. The Data (Use and Access) Act 2025 added a recognised legitimate interests basis to UK GDPR Article 6, limited to purposes listed in Annex 1, such as national security, emergencies, crime and safeguarding. It's a UK GDPR basis. PECR's rule on the device still comes first, with its own exceptions.
Can UK analytics run on an object switch instead of consent?
Sometimes, under the statistics exception the 2025 Act added, which is a separate thing from legitimate interest. The tool has to only count how your own site is used, be explained to visitors and stop when someone objects, and the ICO says its switch may start on. Advertising never fits. Peeky accepts such a switch only if Reject all turns it off too.
How does Peeky check what Reject all leaves on?
Peeky clicks Reject all, then reads the consent record your banner keeps, opens the settings and every vendor list, and reads the banner's wording. Anything still on under legitimate interest is written down with where it was found. How a scan works has the full path.
Filed with
The rule
Privacy and Electronic Communications (EC Directive) Regulations 2003 (PECR), reg. 6, as substituted by the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025, s. 112
Read the rule (Privacy and Electronic Communications (EC Directive) Regulations 2003 (PECR), reg. 6, as substituted by the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025, s. 112)Sources
The law
- PECR 2003, regulation 6 (as substituted 5 February 2026), legislation.gov.uk
- PECR 2003, Schedule A1 (storage and access exceptions), legislation.gov.uk
- Data (Use and Access) Act 2025, section 112 (substitutes PECR regulation 6)
- Data (Use and Access) Act 2025, Schedule 12 (inserts PECR Schedule A1), in force 5 February 2026
- Data (Use and Access) Act 2025, Schedule 13 (PECR enforcement powers)
- Data Protection Act 2018, section 157 (maximum amount of penalty)
- UK GDPR, Article 6 (lawfulness of processing, including recognised legitimate interests)
- UK GDPR, Article 21 (right to object)
- UK GDPR, Annex 1 (recognised legitimate interests)
- The Data (Use and Access) Act 2025 (Commencement No. 9 and Transitional and Saving Provisions) Regulations 2026 (SI 2026/1015): the Information Commission takes over the Information Commissioner's functions on 30 September 2026
Guidance
- ICO, Guidance on the use of storage and access technologies: How do the PECR rules relate to the UK GDPR? (finalised April 2026)
- ICO, Guidance on the use of storage and access technologies: How do the rules apply to online advertising? (finalised April 2026)
- ICO, Guidance on the use of storage and access technologies: What are the exceptions? (finalised April 2026)
- ICO, Guidance on the use of storage and access technologies: How do we manage consent in practice? (finalised April 2026)
- ICO, Update report into adtech and real time bidding, 20 June 2019
- EDPB, Report of the work undertaken by the Cookie Banner Taskforce, adopted 17 January 2023 (EU guidance, for comparison)
Decisions and cases
- AEPD (Spain), resolution of sanctioning procedure PS/00080/2023 (Chatwith.io Worldwide, S.L.), in Spanish
- IMY (Sweden), Tillsynsbeslut Aller Media AB, IMY-2023-16452, 28 April 2025 (in Swedish, the authentic version)
- EDPB register, IMY final decision on Aller Media AB, unofficial English translation
- APD (Belgium), IAB Europe held responsible for a mechanism that infringes the GDPR (2 February 2022)
- APD (Belgium), The Market Court rules in the IAB Europe case (14 May 2025)
Further reading
- IAB Europe, TCF v2.2 FAQ, updated 27 July 2023
- IAB Europe, Transparency and Consent Framework Policies (purposes and allowable lawful bases)
Last checked against the source:
For information only. Not legal advice.
